# PAY-231 GitHub visual walkthrough transcript

1. GitHub issue #1 was created before PR #2. Its first criterion requires two concurrent requests with the same idempotency key to share one gateway charge and charge ID. The first Peertic session saved the issue text as background context.
2. The initial PR implementation stored the key only after awaiting the gateway. Two existing tests passed, but they did not cover concurrent requests.
3. Peertic identified the gap at `src/payments.mjs:14–15`, cited criterion 1, posted an inline GitHub comment, requested changes, and completed a failing check. This is review round 1, session `4cd80da2-e169-4352-ad33-b5d519541478`.
4. A new test reproduced two gateway calls before the fix. The updated implementation stores an in-flight promise before awaiting it and clears the key after failure; all four tests passed.
5. Round 2 found no new issue but incorrectly kept the old thread open because its follow-up context did not include the test file. An AI assistant checked the test and code, replied with the evidence, and resolved the thread.
6. Round 3 returned a neutral check because the PR description's bare `PAY-231` reference triggered an unavailable external lookup. The PR description was clarified to refer only to the linked GitHub issue; the criterion itself was unchanged.
7. Round 4, session `ed66a128-b478-4a13-8f9f-3f36916b1977`, reviewed the full PR, recorded zero findings, posted approval, and completed a successful check. The portal comparison classified the initial finding as resolved.
8. The structured requirement planner still marked issue #1 unverifiable. The final approval therefore shows no blocking code finding and a resolved thread, but it does not prove that all four criteria were automatically verified.

This is a visual walkthrough of recorded product sessions and GitHub API records on a purpose-built private sample repository. The complete evidence package includes the source, tests, diffs, review records, and run IDs.
